Because there's a lack of new players. In other words, the server isn't growing anymore (or at least the forums). Even though I have a feeling people just feel cool to say they've been here for a while, because I know some people are still active on the forums who joined after 2016. I don't care really though lel.
I may have joined recently, but I'm an old member. EDIT: Since I didn't know it wasn't around January 2012, I would have to say a few weeks after the time of its launch
since mid 2013 for sb1, i used to play with my friends after school from 4-9pm when i was in 4th grade. i used to have the biggest headaches and my mum would hate it (rawr ecks dee). but i loved playing on here, i suppose those memories are what help me come back. i remember being a big deal and it was funny having ranked people go out of their way to give me free shit. honestly tho, the only thing keeping this server together are the old collegians and the turks.